How to choose a digital marketing agency: a B2B buyer’s guide

This guide is for B2B companies choosing a digital marketing agency. That means a product that takes explaining, deals worth thousands of dollars, a sales cycle of weeks or months and a sales team that closes. It draws on our calls with such companies since 2015, including companies that came to us after an agency that didn’t work out.

In short

  1. Write down your sales numbers first: deal size, margin, sales cycle and how many new clients would pay for the work.
  2. Shortlist agencies with work in your industry, and ask what that work earned the client.
  3. Read each proposal for a calculation made for your business, with a return-on-investment model.
  4. Call two or three of the agency’s past clients and ask what results they got.
  5. Check the contract: every account in your company’s name, the exit terms and penalties, and who owns the design and code.

Start from your sales numbers

Before you talk to any agency, write down four numbers:

  • your average deal;
  • your margin;
  • how long a deal takes to close;
  • how many new clients a year would make the project worth it.

A serious agency asks for them on the first call, along with your current traffic and how sales are going.

We do the payback math before we start a project. When it shows that a product’s price is too low to pay for the marketing, we say so and turn the project down. An agency that quotes without asking about your numbers is pricing its own hours.

Check work like yours, and what it earned

Look for case studies in your industry or close to it: the same kind of buyer, the same length of sale. Then ask what each project earned the client, in requests, deals or revenue.

Awards tell you little. Manufacturers who came to us after another agency often had an award-style site that looked impressive and brought no new orders. Their existing customers couldn’t find what they needed on it. A well-known agency is no guarantee of a site that sells.

To see what B2B buyers look for on a site, browse our B2B website examples. Manufacturers can compare specialist agencies in our list of manufacturing marketing agencies.

Read the proposal: two signs of a serious agency

When you hold two or three proposals, look for two things:

  • It is written for you. It includes a calculation for your business: what the work costs, what it should bring and when it pays back, as a model you can check. A template with your logo on it means the agency hasn’t looked at your numbers.
  • The case studies match. The examples come from your industry, or one with the same kind of buyer.

Then compare what each proposal includes. A low price often means a smaller scope: fewer pages, no content, no tracking or a template design. Ask each agency to list in writing what the price covers.

Call the agency’s past clients

Ask the agency for two or three clients you can call. Start with one question: what results did you get? Then ask how the agency handled delays, extra requests and problems after launch.

We give our clients’ contacts for these calls. If an agency can’t name a single client who will talk to you, take that as an answer.

Questions to ask at the first meeting

  • What did you look at before this call? A serious agency checks your site on a phone and a desktop before the call. It also checks your request form, what Google and ChatGPT show for your industry, and your competitors.
  • How will you develop the concept, and how will you make sure the result reflects our company?
  • What will you build on? Can we edit the site ourselves and move it to another team?
  • What counts as a result, and how will you report it?

Companies often come to us unable to change their own site, because it is tied to one agency’s system. You should be able to edit your content and move the site whenever you choose.

Agree on what counts as a result

For a B2B company the result is more calls and requests from the buyers you want and more recommendations from AI assistants. In the end it is more revenue. Rankings and traffic are steps on the way. Most of our clients check the monthly report against their own sales.

One limit: an agency brings the requests, and your sales team closes them. When targeted requests come in and deals don’t follow, the sales process needs a look. A good agency will help you with it.

A specialist agency or a generalist

A specialist in your industry is worth it when you plan to buy traffic and run ads. They already know the keywords and what brings qualified leads in your market. For manufacturers, here is how we approach manufacturing marketing.

A generalist works when most clients come from trade shows and referrals and you don’t depend on ads. There the website’s job is to present the company well.

One agency or several

Keep the website and SEO with one agency. When one agency builds the site and another runs the SEO, each problem turns into an argument about whose fault it is. We have seen it happen. Ads can go to a partner agency, as long as the two work together.

What it costs

Among the manufacturers we talk to, a website costs anywhere from about $1,000 to $20,000–30,000. Advertising budgets fall in roughly the same range each month.

For comparison, our own prices:

More on website budgets in How much does a B2B website cost.

Price is a poor way to choose between proposals with different scopes. Compare what each one includes and what it is expected to bring.

Red flags

  • Inflated promises. Guaranteed first-page rankings, a guaranteed number of leads, a traffic forecast for a full year. Google changes how it ranks pages, and no one can promise a position. Clients who ask us for guarantees hear that we don’t give them.
  • Price dumping. A quote far below the others, made to win the deal. The companies that take it often lose money and end up paying for the work twice.
  • No questions about your business before the proposal arrives.
  • No past client willing to talk to you.

What you should own, and what to check in the contract

The domain, the Google Ads account, the Google Business Profile, call-tracking numbers and the CRM should be registered to your company, and the analytics history should leave with you if you change agencies. When an agency hosts your site, make sure you have full access and the right to move it at any time.

In the contract, check three things:

  • How you exit. Can you leave after a stage? Is there a penalty or a minimum term?
  • Who owns the work. The rights to the design, the code and the content should pass to you once you’ve paid.
  • What happens when the scope grows. Extra work should be priced separately, in writing, before it starts.

In our projects you pay stage by stage, the price is fixed in writing before you pay, and you can stop after any stage and keep the work you paid for.

FAQ

How much does a digital marketing agency charge?

It depends on the scope. As a guide, from our own price list: SEO from $750 a month, ads management from $1,000 a month plus ad spend, a five-page website $3,800 and custom websites from $7,500. Ask each agency for a written scope, so you compare the same work.

How long until an agency brings results?

With Google Ads, the first requests can come in the first days, and targeted ones usually by the second or third week. SEO takes two to three months to bring the first leads.

Why hire a digital marketing agency for a B2B company?

The site, the SEO and the ads have to work as one system. Traffic performs badly when the site doesn’t earn trust and convert, so an agency that handles all three can fix every step a buyer takes before sending a request. It pays off when your deal size and margin can cover the marketing, which is why the numbers come first.

What should we prepare before talking to agencies?

Four numbers: your average deal, your margin, how long a deal takes to close and how many new clients a year would make the project worth it. Add your current traffic and how sales are going. With them, an agency can show you a payback calculation for your business.

Start with
one message

Konstantin Tesov
Konstantin TesovFounder, Uwindi
  1. A few lines are enough.
  2. The founder reads every request himself and replies within one business day.
  3. Then a 20-minute call to see whether we are a fit; if we are not, we tell you straight.